Image courtesy: Pfc. David Hauk, U.S. Army. Kandahar, Afghanistan, November 12, 2009

Saturday, March 3, 2012

Where's the Outrage?

Images courtesy: U.S. Air Force/Adrian Rowan

On the rare occasions when U.S. troops make serious mistakes, such as accidentally burning the Koran, there is worldwide outrage. On the frequent occasions when U.S. troops are murdered by terrorists, there is mostly silence.

In January, a video apparently showing a group of Marines urinating on a Taliban corpse swiftly spread across the globe, with The New York Times leading the charge.

"Even after seven years, the photos of Army soldiers abusing detainees at the Abu Ghraib prison are an ugly black mark on the American presence in Iraq," the newspaper's editorial board wrote on Jan. 13. "Now there is a new scar on the country's reputation."

While desecration of the dead cannot be condoned, it is shameful for some national media pundits to condemn an entire all-volunteer military force for the unfortunate actions of a few.

One week before the editorial was published, four Indiana National Guard soldiers — Staff Sgt. Jonathan Metzger, 32; Spc. Robert Tauteris Jr., 44; Spc. Christopher Patterson, 20; and Spc. Brian Leonhardt, 21 — were killed in Afghanistan's Kandahar province when their vehicle was blown up by an improvised explosive device planted by terrorists.

Other than listing the fallen soldiers' names, The New York Times wrote nothing about the deadly attack. Even though terrorists routinely desecrate the bodies of coalition troops and Afghan civilians with crude bombs indiscriminately buried near roadways and schools, killers of American service members are actually given a voice by some national media outlets.

"We strongly condemn the inhuman act of wild American soldiers, as ever, and consider this act in contradiction with all human and ethical norms," a preposterous Taliban statement, published by The New York Times in a Jan. 12 story about the urination video, reads.

The Taliban embodies the word "inhuman." It has harbored Osama bin Laden, raped and tortured thousands of women, murdered defenseless children and robbed our country of some of its best and brightest patriots. Enemy propaganda had no place in America after we were attacked at Pearl Harbor, nor should it after being struck at the World Trade Center, Pentagon and Shanksville, Pa.

On Feb. 22, after copies of the Koran were accidentally burned at Bagram Air Base, The New York Times printed a quote from Abdul Sattar Khawasi, a member of Afghan Parliament, which urged attacks against Americans. The quote will not be re-printed in this column.

Since Khawasi incited terrorism in the pages of an American newspaper and elsewhere, several U.S. troops have been killed and wounded in violent attacks.

The Koran-burning mistake, which elicited immediate apologies from President Barack Obama, Defense Secretary Leon Panetta, and Gen. John Allen, commander of the U.S.-led war effort, received more media attention than the deaths of any U.S. troops since 30 American service members, including 22 Navy SEALs, died in an Aug. 6, 2011, helicopter crash.

The Feb. 10 death of Lance Cpl. Osbrany Montes De Oca, 20, went virtually unnoticed by the national press. That's because even though the Marine was from North Arlington, N.J., just five miles from Newark, where Whitney Houston's memorial service was held, his ultimate sacrifice was deemed by ratings-hungry media executives to be far less important than the death of a pop singer.

Almost every week in this column, you read the words of grieving wives, husbands, moms, dads, sisters and brothers of American troops who have lost their lives in Afghanistan or Iraq.

"Nobody wants it to happen to them," Maria Simpson said after losing her son, Lance Cpl. Abraham Simpson, 19, and then her nephew, Sgt. Jonathan Simpson, 25, in Iraq. "But on the other hand, why should it happen to other people but not me?"

It shouldn't have happened to the Simpson family. It also shouldn't have happened to the families of U.S. troops murdered in Afghanistan after the Taliban used accidental burnings of the Koran to ignite more violence in a country that our brave men and women in uniform have selflessly shielded since 2001.

As Americans, we must ask ourselves why national outrage is rarely directed at our enemies when they kill and maim U.S. troops. While we shouldn't riot in the streets like those trying to tear apart Afghanistan, shouldn't we at least care?



  1. As usual...dead on! There is a reason I don't watch the main stream media anymore and every one of your articles reminds me why! Keep up the good work Tom, someday these Heroes will get the same attention drugged up celebrities do, but until that time, don't stop writing the truth!

  2. Sometimes I am so proud to be an American and sometimes I am so ashamed to be an American.
    We must stop apologizing for the wrong reasons.

    My deepest sympathy to the families who have lost their loved ones.

  3. It is ashame our Leadership can't see or admit that the enemy will use anything we do or nothing we do to kill our troops. They need no reason they hate us. Why would an American Newspaper print propaganda that will endanger our Troops? Why does the Media play up the riots of the AFGH people but not the anger of the American people...because the AMERICAN people sit in their bubble and it does not effect them and they move along in life, but I have learned that is with most things...until it hits them in the out rage. me after 20 years of being a Military wife I will soon have my freedom of speech spouse's final active duty mission is the free his oppressed wife. So our leadership needs to untie our mens hands let them fight to win and protect themselves and stop worrying about being so PC about everything...
    So now our leadership is on a head hunt for some poor fellow soldier to "pay" a price for burning a book that had written messages from prisioners to be sent from prisoner to the AFGH people will be happy....that is the plan well I got an idea
    Put that soldier in a chair and put pink panties on his head....then send him home...or will they want him beheaded???? not bad enough the thought process on this one??? great article...